The Default Tariff You Chose by Doing Nothing: A 45-Day Energy Procurement Reset
Photo: Jaggery , CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Most UK mid-market boards can name their largest customer, their bank covenant and their three biggest cost lines without reaching for a file. Fewer can say, without checking, when the electricity contract expires, what the volume tolerance band is, or how the broker introducing the deal is paid. That gap is not unusual. It is also not cheap.
This is not an argument for re-tendering on principle. It is an argument for testing, on a fixed timetable, whether the contract in force still matches the business that signed it. Companies change shape: a site closes, a shift pattern moves, a new production line doubles overnight consumption. Supply contracts do not change with them. They run to their own clock, and the clock is usually set by the supplier.
The assumptions buried in a fixed price
A fixed unit rate feels like certainty, and for the energy component it often is. The uncertainty simply relocates. Three clauses repay close reading before any renewal conversation begins.
- Volume tolerance. Most fixed contracts carry a take-or-pay band, commonly somewhere between 90 and 110 per cent of agreed volume. Fall short because a site closed or a chiller was replaced, and the company pays for energy it never consumed. Exceed the band, and the excess is charged at an out-of-contract or deemed rate that bears little relation to the headline price.
- Deemed and out-of-contract rates. If a renewal letter went to a former finance director, or landed in a shared inbox during an audit, supply continues. It continues at rates that can be double the prevailing market, applied retrospectively once the lapse is discovered.
- Pass-through charges. Standing charges, capacity charges based on agreed kVA, distribution and transmission use of system, renewable obligation and contracts for difference levies, Climate Change Levy, meter operation and data collection. A fixed unit rate does not fix these. They move, and they are increasingly the difference between a competitive quote and an expensive one.
The commission question nobody asks
Brokers do real work. They navigate supplier credit teams, manage transfer risk and absorb administrative load that most finance functions would rather not carry. The difficulty is that the fee is rarely visible. Commission may take the form of a pence-per-kWh uplift on the supplier rate, a flat fee, or a share of the supplier margin — and only one of those appears cleanly on an invoice.
Boards commissioning a review should ask for disclosure in writing, at the outset, before any letter of authority is signed. The letter of authority itself deserves a look: its scope determines what the broker can commit the company to, and for how long.
Timing is the whole game
Renewal windows commonly open between six and twelve months ahead of contract end, and termination notice periods on rolling contracts can run to 90 days. A contract ending in autumn 2027 may need a decision in spring 2027; a board that starts the conversation in the month before expiry is not procuring, it is accepting.
A practical rule: the renewal date belongs in the corporate calendar next to the audit timetable and the insurance review, with an owner named and a decision date fixed at least two quarters ahead.
The 45-day sprint
The objective is not a new contract. It is a defensible answer to one question: does the current arrangement still fit the business? Forty-five days is enough to find out.
| Days | Workstream | Output |
|---|---|---|
| 1–7 | Gather | Current contract and all schedules, letter of authority, 12 months of invoices, half-hourly data if available, site and meter list |
| 8–14 | Baseline | Consumption profile by site and season, peak kVA, forecast volume for the next 24 months against known operational changes |
| 15–21 | Structure | Board agreement on risk appetite: proportion fixed, proportion flexible, tenor, tolerance band |
| 22–28 | Market test | Two brokers and one direct approach, quoting on a like-for-like basis with all pass-through charges itemised |
| 29–38 | Negotiate | Tolerance band, termination rights, security and credit terms, commission disclosure |
| 39–45 | Decide | One-page board paper, named owner, renewal diary entry, quarterly consumption review added to the management pack |
The most common failure point is day 15. Without an agreed risk appetite, every quote looks either too expensive or too exposed, and the decision drifts past the notice date.
A simple risk matrix for 2026 renewals
| Business condition | Sensible posture | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Stable volumes, thin margins | High fixed proportion, longer tenor | Tolerance band must match forecast closely |
| Volumes falling through efficiency or site closure | Lower fixed volume, hybrid structure | Avoid take-or-pay; negotiate downward flexibility |
| Volumes rising or genuinely uncertain | Hybrid with generous upside tolerance | Check the out-of-contract rate, not just the fixed rate |
| Cash-constrained, covenant-sensitive | Fixed budget certainty, shorter tenor | Security deposits and credit support obligations |
| Multi-site with half-hourly meters | Consider separate procurement by site profile | Aggregation can mask an expensive site |
Questions to put to the broker in writing
- What is your commission, expressed per kWh and as a percentage of total contract value, and over what term is it paid?
- Which suppliers were approached, on what dates, and what did each return?
- What is the volume tolerance band, and what rate applies outside it in each direction?
- What is the termination notice period, and does the contract roll over automatically?
- Which charges in this quote are fixed and which are pass-through?
- What is the cost of early exit, and what security is required?
- Who at the supplier owns our account, and what is the escalation route for billing disputes?
What the board should minute
Four things: the named owner of the contract, the renewal decision date, confirmation that commission disclosure is on file, and the tolerance band recorded against the volume forecast. Add a standing quarterly review of consumption against contract assumptions, because the cheapest time to discover a tolerance breach is before the year ends, not after.
Energy is rarely the largest cost line in a mid-market business, but it is one of the few where a single unsigned letter can move the number by six figures. Forty-five days of structured attention is a modest price for removing that exposure.