Taupo Consulting All articles
Finance & Operations

What One Company Owes Another: A 45-Day Board Review of Intercompany Recharges

Taupo Consulting
What One Company Owes Another: A 45-Day Board Review of Intercompany Recharges

Photo: Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The invoice that arrives after the year has closed

In most UK mid-market groups, the recharge is the last item on the finance team's list. Trading subsidiaries are invoiced for management time in a single year-end journal. Premises costs are apportioned on a percentage that nobody can now explain. Intellectual property is licensed for a nominal sum, or not licensed at all. The arrangement works quietly for years — until a change of ownership, a lender's diligence, an audit query or an HMRC enquiry asks a simple question: what is this charge for, and how was the figure reached?

A defensible answer requires more than an invoice. It requires a pricing logic, a record of the cost being recovered, a contract or board decision that authorises the arrangement, and a settlement that actually happens. Building that position is not a large project, but it does need to be deliberate. The 45-day structure below is designed to fit around a normal reporting cycle.

Why the issue has moved up the agenda

Several pressures converge on related-party charges in 2026. Transfer pricing rules under UK law apply the arm's length principle to transactions between connected companies, and the compliance burden falls most heavily on larger groups while the evidential expectation applies to all. Corporate interest restriction rules require groups to think about how intra-group debt and charges interact. VAT treatment of cost recharges — whether a payment is a disbursement or consideration for a supply — remains a reliable source of error. Employment taxes on seconded staff and the allocation of payroll costs continue to attract scrutiny. Meanwhile, statutory accounts prepared under FRS 102 require related-party disclosures that are increasingly read alongside the tax computation.

The common thread is documentation. A group that can produce a coherent file within a few days of a request is in a materially different position from one that must reconstruct its reasoning from memory.

Four questions the board should be able to answer

Before any detailed work begins, the board or audit committee should test itself against four questions. What is being recharged, and to which entity? On what basis is the price set? What evidence supports the cost and the allocation? Who approved the arrangement, and when was it last reviewed?

If any answer begins with "we've always done it that way", that is the area to examine first. The purpose of the exercise is not to eliminate judgement — allocation always involves judgement — but to make that judgement explicit, consistent and recorded.

Weeks one and two: inventory and map

The first task is a complete list. Every flow of value between group companies should be identified: management and director time, shared services such as finance and IT, property and utilities, vehicle and equipment use, licences for brands and systems, intra-group loans and guarantees, and the recharging of third-party costs. Include items that are provided free of charge; an unpriced benefit is still a related-party transaction and may carry transfer pricing, VAT or employment tax consequences.

For each item, record the payer, the recipient, the annual value, the mechanism (invoice, journal, credit note, none) and the person who owns the arrangement. Where an intercompany agreement exists, attach it. Where it does not, note the gap. This register becomes the spine of the review and the first document a reviewer will ask for.

Weeks three and four: test the pricing basis

With the map complete, examine the logic behind each charge. Three broad approaches are common: direct cost recovery, cost plus a mark-up, and a market-based or comparable price. None is inherently wrong, but each must match the facts.

A cost-plus recharge needs a defined cost pool, a documented allocation key and a stated mark-up with a rationale. A market-based charge needs a comparable — an external quote, a published rate, a third-party benchmark — retained on file. A nil or nominal charge needs an explanation that survives scrutiny, not merely an assumption that it is convenient.

Pay particular attention to allocation keys. Headcount, floor area, revenue and time records are all defensible, but only if they are applied consistently and refreshed. A key set in 2019 and never updated is a weakness, not a policy. Where a key changes, record why.

Weeks five and six: documentation, governance and remediation

Documentation should be proportionate. A group of any size should hold an intercompany agreement or a board minute for each material arrangement, a schedule of charges with the pricing basis, and a file evidencing the underlying costs. Larger groups within the scope of formal transfer pricing documentation requirements will need a master file and local file; smaller entities should still be able to explain their position in a short memorandum.

Governance matters as much as paperwork. A recharge policy approved by the board, reviewed annually and applied consistently is strong evidence of commercial intent. So is evidence of settlement: intercompany balances that roll forward indefinitely invite questions about whether the charge was ever really made. Consider credit terms, interest on overdue balances and periodic clearing of positions.

The final week should produce a remediation plan rather than a report that sits unread. Prioritise by exposure: employment tax and VAT errors, unpriced benefits, missing agreements for material flows, and any charge that cannot be supported by evidence. Assign owners and dates, and report progress to the next audit committee.

The enquiry that arrives before the paperwork

HMRC does not usually open with a demand for the full file. It asks a focused question about one charge, in one year, and reads the reply for signs of a system. A group that responds within days with a register, an agreement, a pricing rationale and a cost schedule ends the conversation quickly. A group that responds with an estimate invites a wider look.

The 45 days are best spent making the second scenario unnecessary. The work is unglamorous, but it is the kind of groundwork that protects the group's position long after the current financial year has closed.

All Articles

Related Articles

A Ledger With a Name Attached: Thirty Days to Reconcile Director Loans

A Ledger With a Name Attached: Thirty Days to Reconcile Director Loans

The Pledges Missing from the Pack: A 45-Day Guarantee Register for UK Boards

The Pledges Missing from the Pack: A 45-Day Guarantee Register for UK Boards

The Covenants Behind the Award: A 45-Day Grant Conditions Review for UK Boards

The Covenants Behind the Award: A 45-Day Grant Conditions Review for UK Boards